Your overall paper review format is shown on the next page but shown
below with additional comments on assignment for review:
1 – 3 paragraphs to Introduce the Paper.
Paragraph 1 – Summarize the paper leading to a statement on the
problem/question needing research and the paper’s main conclusion as well
as a very brief description of the key experimental approach used to answer
the problem/question. What is the impact of this research in the field. Also,
include other information from below on what to include in the first paragraph.
Paragraph 2 – Give your overall impression of the paper (see the information
below).
Paragraph 3 – Split the major problems and minor problems under these
headings and add text in each of them as bullet points (shown below as
example). Refer to pages where the problem is located. Write to help the
authors produce a better paper. Don’t try to change the paper’s message by
stating additional experiments. You can suggests use of other experiments for
a stronger result but don’t add new experiments that don’t help them (just
adds more work for them).